Historical Accuracy of Profarmer Crop Tour

Profarmer Crop Tour – History of Results verses National Agriculture Statistics Service

Each August, Profarmer goes into the major corn and soybean producing states and survey’s fields and develops an estimate of what yields will be.

Methodology - Corn

Crop scouts enter the field beyond the end rows and they recommend walking 35 paces past the end rows. They measure the row width and hook a 30' length of rope on a corn stalk. Next, scouts count the number of ears in two rows along the rope, and pull the 5th, 8th and 11th ears from one of the rows.
 
The scouts husk the ears, measure the length of cob and count the number of kernels rows around.  An average of the number of earns in the two rows is calculated.  Then an average of the grain length is taken of the 3 cobs pulled and an average of the kernel rows.

They the scouts plug it into the formula:

Ear count (X) x grain length (Y) x kernel rows (Z) = 5460/row width (30') = ABC bushels per acre.
 
Methodology - Soybeans

Crop scouts enter the field, get past the field's end rows and use a measuring tape to determine row width and define a 3' section of a row. They count all of the plants in the row and then pull three random plants from it.

Then scouts count pods on each plant and figure an average pod-per-plant count. Then scouts plug their numbers into this formula (I inserted numbers for this example):

Number of plants in 3' (X) x Average number of pods per plant (Y) = Pods in 3' (Z) x 36 (makes it a square) = ABC/row spacing (15) = 1176 pods in a 3' by 3' square.

All above methodology is sourced from https://www.dtnpf.com/agriculture/ag/blogs/market-matters-blog/blog-post/2013/08/19/crop-tour-arrives-yield-estimates
 
Historically accuracy of the Profarmer tour

Based on history from 2003, the Profarmer tour is very accurate in predicting  both the September National Agriculture Statistics Service (NASS) yield estimate and the NASS Final yield estimate (released in January of the following year).

On average, the corn estimate is off by 0.31 bushels when compared to the September NASS yield estimate and is off by 2.03 bushels when compared to the Final Year-end NASS yield estimate.

On average, the soybean estimate is off by 0.27 bushels when compared to the September NASS yield estimate and is off by 0.99 bushels when compared to the Final Year-end NASS yield estimate.
 
The data from each Yield Tour is below;

Corn

 

 

 

 

 

 

Year

Pro Farmer

NASS September

NASS Final

Profarmer less NASS Sept

Profarmer less NASS Final

Source for Profarmer Data

2003

139.1

138.5

142.2

0.6

-3.1

1

2004

147.3

149.4

160.3

-2.1

-13

1

2005

136.6

143.2

147.9

-6.6

-11.3

1

2006

151.5

154.7

149.1

-3.2

2.4

1

2007

153.5

155.8

150.7

-2.3

2.8

1

2008

153.3

152.3

153.9

1

-0.6

1

2009

160.1

161.9

164.7

-1.8

-4.6

1

2010

164.1

162.5

152.8

1.6

11.3

1

2011

147.9

148.1

147.2

-0.2

0.7

1

2012

120.3

122.7

123.3

-2.4

-3

1

2013

154.1

155.3

158.8

-1.2

-4.7

1

2014

169.3

147.4

171

21.9

-1.7

1

2015

168.8

167.5

168.4

1.3

0.4

1

2016

170.2

169.6

174.6

0.6

-4.4

1

2017

167.1

169.9

176.6

-2.8

-9.5

2

2018

177.3

181.3

176.4

-4

0.9

3

2019

163.3

168.2

168

-4.9

-4.7

4

2020

177.5

178.5

172

-1

5.5

5

2021

177

 

 

 

 

6

Average difference

 

 

-0.31

-2.03

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Soybeans

 

 

 

 

 

 

Year

Pro Farmer

NASS September

NASS Final

Profarmer less NASS Sept

Profarmer less NASS Final

Source for Profarmer Data

2003

37.7

36.4

33.9

1.3

3.8

1

2004

37.9

38.5

42.2

-0.6

-4.3

1

2005

38.5

39.6

43.1

-1.1

-4.6

1

2006

40.9

41.8

42.9

-0.9

-2

1

2007

42

41.4

41.7

0.6

0.3

1

2008

40

40

39.6

0

0.4

1

2009

41

42.3

44

-1.3

-3

1

2010

44.9

44.7

43.5

0.2

1.4

1

2011

41.8

41.8

41.5

0

0.3

1

2012

34.8

35.3

39.6

-0.5

-4.8

1

2013

41.8

41.2

43.3

0.6

-1.5

1

2014

45.4

45.4

47.8

0

-2.4

1

2015

46.5

47.1

48

-0.6

-1.5

1

2016

49.3

49.4

52.1

-0.1

-2.8

1

2017

48.5

49.9

49.1

-1.4

-0.6

2

2018

53

52.8

50.6

0.2

2.4

3

2019

46.1

47.9

47.4

-1.8

-1.3

4

2020

52.5

51.9

50.2

0.6

2.3

5

2021

51.2

 

 

 

 

6

Average difference

 

 

-0.27

-0.99

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

References

 

 

 

 

 

1 - https://agresource.com/33257-2/

 

 

 

 

2 - https://ocj.com/2017/08/2017-farm-journal-midwest-crop-tour-summary/

 

3 - https://ocj.com/tag/pro-farmer-crop-tour/

 

 

 

4 - https://ocj.com/2019/08/final-estimates-in-from-2019-pro-farmer-midwest-crop-tour/

5 - https://www.profarmer.com/news/agriculture-news/pro-farmer-crop-tour-fact-finding-mission

6 - https://www.agweb.com/markets/market-analysis/jerry-gulke-politics-weather-and-pro-farmer-crop-tour-take-prices-lower